The Importance of Hadith Criticism Today

Noble Shaykh, Professor Dr Muḥammad Akram — may Allah preserve him — al-salāmu ʿalaykum wa-raḥmatullāh wa-barakātuh.

I have the honour of submitting an academic query raised by one of our second-year ʿĀliyah students, whose name is ʿUbayd al-Raḥmān, during the lecture “Uṣūl al-Ḥadīth”. He asked:

“We study, within ḥadīth terminology, the topic of ‘al-ḥadīth al-muʿallal’, which is among the subtlest and most elusive branches of ḥadīth studies. Are there, in our own age, critics who are specialised and competent in this delicate discipline? And is there still an acute need for such deep critical studies in our time?”

I have deemed that the best person to answer is your noble self, in view of your firm footing and recognised pioneering in this field, and in the hope that the spread of your reply will bring widespread benefit to the seekers of knowledge.

We request your esteemed response. May Allah reward you with the best recompense on behalf of knowledge and its people.

Your brother in Allah,
Muḥammad Salmān al-Bajnūrī al-Nadwī
(Lecturer, Dār al-ʿUlūm, Nadwat al-ʿUlamāʾ)

Asked:
Shaykh Akram Nadwi
Answer from

Shaykh Akram Nadwi

Principal, Al-Salam Institute · Founding Scholar, ASI Research Centre for Islamic Studies

Answered on


Wa-ʿalaykum al-salām wa-raḥmatullāhi wa-barakātuh. In reply to the scholarly question posed by our honourable brother ʿUbayd al-Raḥmān concerning the extent to which the need for specialists in the science of the hidden defects of ḥadīth (ʿIlal al-Ḥadīth) continues in our present age, I say — seeking the aid of Allah, Exalted is He:

The science of ʿilal al-ḥadīth is among the most intricate of the sciences of the Prophetic Sunnah and the most concealed in its pathways; it is one of the noblest disciplines of ḥadīth criticism and has the greatest impact in safeguarding the Sunnah and distinguishing what is sound from what is unsound. Its purpose is to uncover those subtle, latent causes that undermine the authenticity of a ḥadīth, causes that do not become apparent merely through examining the outward isnād or through a general scrutiny of the narrators’ biographies.

Not everyone who has mastered the names of the narrators and their ranks, nor everyone who has comprehended the criteria for ṣaḥīḥ ḥadīth, is qualified to enter this discipline. Rather, it is the arena of the imams who are consummate critics: those whose feet are firmly planted in the knowledge of ḥadīth and its pathways, whose memories contain vast reserves of narrations, whose experience with the reports is lengthy, and who possess the ability for precise comparison between the various modes of transmission in both isnād and matn, thereby deriving the errors and defects that may have crept in.

From this standpoint, the presence of scholars proficient in ʿilal al-ḥadīth within this Ummah in every age is indispensable, and the need for this discipline is not terminated by the mere passage of time, nor is it satisfied by the recording of the verdicts of the earlier imams. The safeguarding of the Prophetic Sunnah demands that there remain a group from among the people of knowledge who possess the critical aptitude required to understand the subtleties of this science, to grasp the methodologies of its imams, to verify their judgements, and to examine the narrations in the light of their principles and rules.

It must be pointed out that many a ḥadīth may, on the face of its chain, appear to have fulfilled the conditions of authenticity — even the transmitters may belong to those whose narrations are found in the two Ṣaḥīḥs — yet that very ḥadīth is subject to hidden, damaging defects that prevent the ruling of authenticity. The defect might arise from tadlīs, or irsāl, or a mistake wherein a mawqūf narration has been erroneously raised to marfūʿ, or a mursal has been connected; it may stem from a trustworthy narrator contradicting one who is even more trustworthy, or from interpolation within the isnād or text, inversion in the narration, or inconsistency in its transmission. Such matters are perceived only by one seasoned in this discipline, acquainted with the methods of the imams in uncovering defects and weighing narrations.

Thus the essential difference between superficial criticism and causal criticism becomes clear. The first may halt at noting the apparent connectedness of the chain and the uprightness and precision of its narrators, whereas the second goes beyond that to survey all the routes, to collect the various narrations, to compare the modes of divergence, to examine the supporting indicators, and to discover the underlying causes of error and flaw. For this reason the science of ʿilal is a particular hallmark of the eminent specialists in ḥadīth, not a field open to everyone who merely practises takhrīj or pronounces on chains from their outward aspect.

Through this one may comprehend an important aspect of the methodology of the two imams al-Bukhārī and Muslim — may Allah have mercy upon them — in their selection of the material they placed in their Ṣaḥīḥs. They did not commit themselves to narrating every report whose chain appeared ṣaḥīḥ at first sight; rather, they exercised a most exacting consideration of hidden defects and variations that would not be apparent to one who confines himself to studying the outward chain. Hence, their omission of a particular ḥadīth does not necessarily signify its weakness, just as the outer fulfilment of the conditions of authenticity does not suffice to judge that the ḥadīth met their standards of selection and critique.

In a number of later works and studies we frequently encounter pronouncements such as: “This is a ṣaḥīḥ ḥadīth according to the criteria of the two Shaykhs although they did not include it,” or: “This is a ṣaḥīḥ ḥadīth according to the criteria of al-Bukhārī although he did not narrate it,” or: “This is a ṣaḥīḥ ḥadīth according to the criteria of Muslim although he did not narrate it.” By these expressions the author intends that, in his view, the ḥadīth possesses the conditions observed by al-Bukhārī or Muslim in their Ṣaḥīḥs, even though one or both of them did not record it.

Such verdicts ought not to be based merely on an inspection of the names of the transmitters, or on the fact that they are of those to whom the two Shaykhs gave inclusion in their collections. The soundness of a ḥadīth does not rest exclusively on the integrity and precision of the narrators and the connectedness of the chain; it is also necessary to ascertain the mode of transmission between them, and to ensure that the chain is free of shudhūdh and of hidden, undermining defects. A chain could consist wholly of narrators found in the two Ṣaḥīḥs and be outwardly connected, yet the ḥadīth might still contain a subtle defect that impedes a judgement of authenticity.

It therefore becomes clear that the mere convergence of narrators from the two Ṣaḥīḥs within a single chain is not enough to declare that the ḥadīth fulfils their criteria, let alone to assert its soundness on that basis alone. One must know the methodology of the two imams in selection and criticism, examine all the routes of the ḥadīth, study its various narrations, and detect whatever hidden defects it may contain. A ḥadīth that later scholars have been pleased to declare sound on the criteria of the two Shaykhs may well have been left out by al-Bukhārī or Muslim because they knew of a damaging defect therein, unseen by those who came after and who confined their attention to the apparent chain without delving deeply into the divergences among the narrations.

It is precisely this that reveals the importance of the science of ʿilal: it shows that ruling a ḥadīth authentic is not a mechanical exercise based on checking narrators’ names; rather, it is the fruit of meticulous criticism founded upon gathering the routes, weighing them one against another, knowing the ranks of the transmitters, and distinguishing the preserved from the erroneous. Were the outward scrutiny of the chain sufficient for issuing a verdict of authenticity, the Ummah would have had no need for this delicate science, nor would the imams of ḥadīth have enjoyed the distinction for which they are renowned.

What leads some of the later scholars to such verdicts is their limiting themselves to the outward chain whilst lacking comprehensive knowledge of the pathways of the critical imams in detecting defects, or their failure to be fully aware of the variants and the indicators that afford preference to one narration over another. If one were to examine the books of ʿilal and to study the judgements of the earlier scholars regarding those aḥādīth whose chains appear sound, it would become evident that many of those judgements rest upon subtle critical reasoning. Much that appears to a later observer to be a ḥadīth fulfilling the conditions may in fact fall short of the rank of authenticity on account of a hidden defect. This confirms that issuing verdicts on ḥadīth is not sound merely by inspecting the biographical entries of the narrators or by applying the criteria of authenticity in a mechanical fashion, without encompassing the methods of the critics and their ways of weighing and preferring.

The need for this science in our age is therefore not supplementary, nor an academic luxury; it is a fundamental necessity that touches the core of ḥadīth studies. Consequently, academic institutions, universities and Sharʿī institutes must devote attention to training researchers in this specialism, and the energies of the students of knowledge ought to be directed towards studying the books of ʿilal through analytical and applied reading, not confined to memorising terms and definitions but extending to practical criticism, gathering routes, comparing chains and texts, and gaining an intimate grasp of the fine judgements and rationales of the imams.

Foremost among the sources to which such care should be attached are the works of the earlier critics, such as Imām ʿAlī ibn al-Madīnī, Imām Aḥmad ibn Ḥanbal, Imām al-Bukhārī, Imām Muslim, the two imams Abū Ḥātim and Abū Zurʿah al-Rāzī, Imām al-Tirmidhī, Imām al-Nasāʾī, Imām al-Dāraquṭnī and others of the giants in this field — may Allah have mercy upon them all. Observing the praxis of these imams, tracing their critical applications, and assimilating their methods in identifying defects is the surest path to acquiring the ḥadīth critical faculty, a capacity that is not gained through theoretical acquaintance alone.

This does not mean that every researcher in ḥadīth is obliged to become a far-reaching critic in ʿilal, nor that whoever has not reached the rank of the earlier imams is debarred from research in this area. What is intended is that in the Ummah there should remain a number of specialised scholars who combine sound theoretical grounding with practical application, possessing the tools of criticism that qualify them to probe the subtleties of the narrations, while remaining bound by scholarly decorum, humility before the verdicts of the imams, and caution against haste in venturing to correct what may have been hidden from those not specialised.

As for the claim that the age of the critical imams has passed, and that the science of ʿilal no longer has any practical relevance in our time, such a claim is incompatible with the nature and function of this discipline. The recording of the verdicts of the earlier scholars does not obviate the need to understand them; collecting the issues of ʿilal does not replace insight into the methodologies of those who formulated them; and memorising the rules cannot substitute for acquiring the critical faculty that is formed through long practice and frequent examination of narrations.

Let it therefore be known that the science of ʿilal al-ḥadīth is not a historical discipline whose usefulness ended with the passing of the earlier generations. It is an essential pillar of ḥadīth criticism and a scholarly necessity for preserving the Prophetic Sunnah and protecting its narrations from error and illusion. This Ummah must possess, in every age, scholars who are critics, cognisant of the defects of ḥadīth, adept in the pathways of the discipline, capable of distinguishing between what is outwardly sound and what is in truth free of undermining defects. The survival of this specialism as a living discipline among the Ummah is not merely the maintenance of a venerable intellectual heritage; it is the continuation of the duty of scrutiny and verification carried forth by the imams of ḥadīth, generation after generation.