Wa ʿalaykum al-salām wa raḥmat Allāh wa barakātuh. You have drawn attention to an exceedingly important and thought-provoking matter. This question is not confined to the milieu of the madāris or to the conduct of some scholars; rather, it is intimately related to the very purpose of religious knowledge, to the reality of īmān, and to the interrelationship of taʿlīm and tarbiyah. In addressing it we must neither overlook the great religious and scholarly services of the madāris, nor turn a blind eye to certain moral and practical weaknesses within them. Sincere goodwill demands that we comprehend the issue free of bias and strive for its rectification.
To grasp the root of the problem, we must first understand the distinction between ʿilm and īmān. ʿIlm is not īmān. ʿIlm denotes knowing a reality, being acquainted with its proofs and affirming its soundness; whereas īmān is true certainty, trust, tranquillity and surrender to Allāh, to His promises and threats, and to His commands and guidance. A person may know many things and concede their validity, yet that does not necessarily make those truths sovereign over his intentions, desires and practical life. The essence of īmān is that the command of Allāh prevails over a person’s desire, His pleasure over worldly benefit, and His promise over outward circumstances.
For that reason the necessary demand of īmān is ʿamal. ʿAmal is not a mere external addendum to īmān; it is the manifestation of its force and veracity. This does not imply that every lapse in action nullifies īmān, but persistent weakness in practice and indifference to the divine commands may indicate feebleness of īmān. The stronger the certainty and trust in Allāh, the more vigorous the impulse to obey Him.
The Qurʾān, when listing the objectives of the mission of the Messenger ﷺ, grants fundamental importance to tazkiyat al-nufūs alongside the teaching of the Book and wisdom:
“He it is who has sent among the unlettered ones a Messenger from among themselves, reciting to them His āyāt, purifying them and teaching them the Book and the wisdom” (al-Jumuʿah: 2).
Likewise: “Only those of His servants who possess knowledge truly fear Allāh” (Fāṭir: 28).
These āyāt make clear that the desired effect of knowledge is khashyah of Allāh and tazkiyah of the soul. Knowledge should make a person feel the greatness of Allāh, instil in him an awareness of accountability and refine his character. If knowledge is increasing yet humility, ikhlāṣ, integrity, good manners and observance of people’s rights are not being cultivated, then we must examine the purpose of our knowledge and our relationship to it.
In our madāris, praiseworthy attention is devoted to the acquisition and teaching of Qurʾān, ḥadīth, fiqh, tafsīr and other sciences. This is a magnificent religious service. The real question, however, is whether we obtain these sciences merely to know and to teach them, or also to have īmān in them and to implement their demands in our lives. To read the censure of ḥasad is one thing; to cleanse the heart of ḥasad is another. To know the prohibition of ghībah is one thing; to guard one’s tongue from violating others’ honour is another. To relate the virtues of tawāḍuʿ is one thing; to be truly humble oneself is another. When the first aspect of knowledge exists but the second does not, a fundamental gap between taʿlīm and tarbiyah becomes manifest.
The question then arises: does the abundance of study and teaching diminish the efficacy of knowledge? In my view, the issue is not the profusion of knowledge, but heedlessness of its purpose. When study becomes a mere intellectual pastime, teaching a means of livelihood, and the acquisition of knowledge a ladder to fame, office or social superiority, the real aim of knowledge recedes into the background. Knowledge, which was meant to bow a person before Allāh, sometimes becomes a means for exalting his ego. Instead of seeking truth, he defends his own opinion; instead of self-reform, he pursues the reform of others; instead of service, he is preoccupied with proving his scholarly superiority.
At this juncture knowledge may become a trial rather than a blessing. The Qurʾān censures those who exult in the knowledge they possess:
“When their Messengers brought them clear proofs, they rejoiced in the knowledge that was with them” (Ghāfir: 83).
The true demand of knowledge is to submit before the truth, not to vaunt one’s learning. Being an ʿālim does not exempt a person from the discipline of the sharīʿah; rather, it increases his responsibility. The Qurʾān declares:
“O you who believe, why do you say what you do not do? It is most hateful in the sight of Allāh that you say what you do not do” (al-Ṣaff: 2–3).
These āyāt contain a severe warning against the discrepancy between knowledge and practice. Yet it is also a reality that the scholar is human; he may err and is in need of rectification. The real corruption appears when a person, instead of acknowledging his deficiency, employs his scholarly stature to justify it. The honour of the ʿālim lies not merely in his knowledge, but in his endeavour to live in accordance with that knowledge.
You have mentioned mutual rancour, envy and resentment at others’ advancement—this too is a significant facet of the moral crisis. In scholarly circles the fame of a person, his writings, his popularity in teaching, the progress of his institution or his academic success may, at times, become distasteful to others. Yet if our aim is the service of religion, we should rejoice at anyone’s religious and scholarly success. Religion is not the private property of any one individual or institution; every sincere effort augments the collective scholarly capital of the ummah.
The Messenger of Allāh ﷺ said: “Do not envy one another, do not nurse rancour, do not turn your backs on one another; rather, be—O servants of Allāh—brothers” (Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī, Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim). Scholarly disagreement is a valuable part of our intellectual heritage, but to convert disagreement into rancour, disdain, suspicion and personal rivalry is contrary to the ethos of both knowledge and religion. To differ with a person’s view cannot justify an assault on his intention or a diminution of his scholarly standing.
For the rectification of this situation we must, first and foremost, attend to the reformation and renewal of our īmān. Instead of treating īmān as an inherited identity or a verbal assertion, we must adopt it as genuine trust in Allāh and surrender before His commands. Second, we should pursue knowledge with the intention that our īmān be strengthened, our maʿrifah of Allāh enhanced and our practical life moulded by His commands. Third, the study of the Qurʾān and the Sīrah of the Prophet ﷺ should not be merely for teaching and citation, but for tadabbur, guidance and self-reform. Fourth, we should study the lives of the ṣaḥābah and the tābiʿūn; they did not merely read the religion, they embodied it. Their lives present a beautiful synthesis of knowledge, īmān, ʿibādah, ikhlāṣ, humility and mutual love.
In this connection, the great work of Imām Dhahabī, Siyar Aʿlām al-Nubalāʾ, is extremely beneficial. It shows that, for our predecessors, the criterion of scholarly greatness was not the mere abundance of information or of works and teaching, but also taqwā, courage in speaking the truth, scholarly honesty, worship and good character. Likewise, Imām Ibn al-Jawzī’s Ṣayd al-Khāṭir grants a person deep insight into his inner self, the stratagems of the nafs, sincerity, the craving for fame and self-accountability. Shaykh al-Islām Ibn Taymiyyah’s al-ʿUbūdiyyah is of the utmost importance for understanding the reality of servitude and for realising that the true aim of human life is the love, obedience and complete servitude of Allāh.
The study of these three works is of uncommon significance for our scholarly and moral training: one teaches us to examine our own souls, another clarifies the purpose of ʿubūdiyyah, and the third presents practical models of knowledge and action.
Fifth, we must seek the company of righteous, sincere and practising people. Man is trained not only by books but also by living examples. We should frequent those gatherings wherein knowledge is coupled with sincerity, character with humility and life with a manifest relationship to Allāh. Sixth, we should be concerned with our own reformation rather than the faults of others. Maintain ḥusn al-ẓann regarding others, rejoice at their success and, as far as possible, avoid speaking ill of anyone. If one truly intends someone’s rectification, it should be pursued with goodwill and wisdom, not through backbiting, disdain and publicity. It is possible that the person whose weakness we observe possesses virtues hidden from our sight, whilst our own weaknesses are concealed from us.
Seventh—and most important—we must always maintain a relationship of duʿāʾ with Allāh. The tawfīq of knowledge, īmān and ʿamal is His gift alone. Make dhikr, tawbah, istighfār and intimate supplication permanent parts of life. The Messenger of Allāh ﷺ was wont to pray frequently: “Yā muqallib al-qulūb, thabbit qalbī ʿalā dīnik—O Turner of hearts, keep my heart firm upon Your religion.” When the Messenger ﷺ would pray for the steadfastness of his own heart, how much more concerned should we be about our īmān and ʿamal!
Within this reformative endeavour, the system of the madāris also bears responsibility. Together with instruction there must be tarbiyah; alongside teaching, tazkiyat al-nafs; and together with academic advancement, moral edification. The practical example of the teachers, the etiquette of disagreement, justice, consultation, transparency and protection of the students’ self-respect are integral to the educational process. The success of the madāris should not be measured solely by the number of graduates, but also by the extent to which they possess sincerity, integrity, humility, truthfulness, public service and an awareness of people’s rights.
The most crucial point in this whole matter is that reform must begin, not with others, but with oneself. It is easy to say that the teachers are arrogant, the students envious and the administrators unjust; but the real question is: am I myself free from these diseases? The Qurʾān affirms: “Indeed, Allāh does not change the condition of a people until they change what is within themselves” (al-Raʿd: 11). Before we hold others to account, we must hold our own souls to account. If every teacher, every student and every administrator strives for self-reform, the atmosphere of the institutions may likewise change.
In conclusion, I reiterate that the essential purpose of the madāris is not merely to produce ʿulamāʾ, but to prepare such ʿulamāʾ whose knowledge strengthens their īmān, whose īmān refines their ʿamal, and whose ʿamal illuminates their character; who bow before the truth, deal with people in justice and iḥsān, rejoice at others’ success, and, despite their scholarly status, adopt humility.
We need a scholar who not only condemns envy but strives to purge his heart of it; who, while declaring the prohibition of backbiting, guards his own tongue; who, while teaching the virtues of humility, is himself humble; and whose life is a living exemplar of Islam’s moral teachings.
The honour of knowledge does not grant a person the right to feel superior to others; rather, it makes him more responsible before them. Knowledge grants recognition of the truth, īmān teaches submission to that truth, and ʿamal renders that submission a reality in life. Along with the abundance of knowledge we must be concerned for its efficacy, together with teaching for tarbiyah, and side by side with scholarly repute for taqwā and ikhlāṣ.
May Allāh make our madāris centres of a beautiful synthesis of knowledge and īmān, action and sincerity, morals and character. May He make our teachers, students and administrators true representatives of their knowledge, purify our hearts from envy, pride, rancour and self-admiration, grant us the tawfīq to act upon the demands of our īmān, and bestow upon us knowledge that is beneficial, īmān that is firmly rooted, ʿamal that is accepted and character that mirrors the sunnah of His Messenger ﷺ.